The idea for this project actually came to me a little over a year ago, during Nigel’s cinematography class in my first term. We were discussing the differences between theatre and film, and one thing that stuck with me was how differently the two mediums handle an audience’s attention. In theatre, you have a whole stage in front of you. You can look wherever you want, pay attention to one character, or completely ignore what’s happening somewhere else. With film, it’s different. The filmmaker decides what you see through the camera, the framing, the editing and pretty much everything else.
That got me thinking: why does a film always have to tell you where to look? I started wondering what it would be like to create something where the audience could feel more like they were actually inside the environment, rather than just watching everything through a camera. I was interested in the idea of giving people more freedom to explore a space and, hopefully, making them feel more connected to whatever was happening in it. At that point, I didn’t have a very specific format in mind. I just knew I wanted to make something immersive.
Why Emotional Neglect?
When I started thinking further about this idea and what it should actually be about, I knew I wanted to explore something human. I wasn’t particularly interested in making a horror experience, which felt like an obvious direction when making something immersive. I wanted to try something a little more grounded, but still emotionally engaging. Eventually, I settled on emotional neglect and dysfunctional family relationships. It’s a subject I have a personal connection to and something I’ve wanted to explore for a while. I wouldn’t describe the film as a retelling of my own life, though. It’s more that I’ve experienced and understood certain feelings that I wanted to find a way to communicate.
One thing I’ve always found interesting about emotional neglect is how difficult it can be to explain. With physical abuse or verbal abuse, there are usually specific things you can point to. Someone says something horrible, someone gets hurt, there’s an argument. You can show those things happening on screen. But emotional neglect is often about things that don’t happen. It’s the lack of attention, the lack of affection, the conversations that never happen, or the feeling that nobody is really paying attention to you.
It was also important to me to not make a film where one parent was obviously the villain and the other was obviously the victim. I was more interested in a situation where both adults might genuinely believe they’re doing their best, or might each feel that they’re the one being wronged, while the child is the one caught in the middle. I think that’s what makes these situations particularly difficult to talk about. When there’s no obvious person to blame, it becomes much harder to explain why something feels wrong. And sometimes, the silence gets louder than anything anyone could actually say.
Why a Child?
I knew quite early on that I wanted the story to be told from a child’s perspective. Part of that was my personal connection to the subject, but I also thought about how different it is to experience these situations as a child rather than an adult. An adult can potentially leave an uncomfortable situation, move somewhere else or make decisions about their circumstances. A child doesn’t really have that freedom. They’re dependent on the same people who might be making their home environment difficult to live in. That’s their entire world. They don’t necessarily have anywhere else to go.
I was also interested in how a child might understand what’s happening around them. Children don’t always understand the problems adults have with each other. They might notice that something feels off, but they don’t necessarily know why. They can sense the tension without being able to explain it. That’s something I really wanted the audience to experience. I didn’t just want people to feel sorry for the child. I wanted them to feel like the child. I wanted them to feel as though they were sitting in the middle of this household, noticing all these little things happening around them, but not really understanding what’s going on or being able to do anything about it.
In a strange way, I wanted the film itself to neglect the audience. The audience is supposed to be part of the experience, but instead of being given all the attention and control, they’re sometimes just left sitting there, watching things happen around them.
The Original Idea : A 360-degree Experience
The idea eventually developed into something somewhere between a VR game and a 360-degree film.I imagined the audience being placed inside a complete 360-degree environment, with the freedom to look wherever they wanted. The overall story would still be the same, but different things would happen or become visible depending on where the viewer was looking.
For example, there might be a conversation happening in one room, while something else was happening behind another door. The television might reveal another little piece of information about the household. Rather than having completely separate storylines, these would all be different pieces of the same story.
I also wanted to experiment with how the experience could respond to where someone was looking. Looking away from an argument might make the sound quieter or cause the image to become blurry. Looking directly at something could produce a different response. I was particularly interested in making some of these interactions subconscious. I didn’t want the audience to constantly feel like they were playing a game or pressing buttons to make things happen. Ideally, the experience would respond to them without them always realizing it.
One idea I was especially excited about was playing with the audience’s expectations. Imagine that at the beginning, you learn that whenever you look away from something uncomfortable, the sound becomes quieter or the image loses focus. Eventually, you get used to that. You start to feel like you can control how much of the uncomfortable situation you have to experience. Then, at some point, the relationship. Suddenly, looking away might make the sound louder, or the thing you’re trying to avoid might become more difficult to ignore.I liked the idea of letting the audience learn how something works, become comfortable with it, and then taking that comfort away.
Moving Away From VR
I discussed this concept with Anis, a friend and alumni who came to give a talk about his final major project. He had graduated the previous year and made a film that I really admired. I explained my idea to him, and he suggested that I look into using a curved widescreen display with eye tracking instead of VR.
I thought this was a really interesting direction. It meant I could still give the audience a much wider field of view without having to put a headset on them. I could also potentially keep the eye-tracking aspect and experiment with things like zoom, depth of field and other visual effects based on where people were looking. There were also some practical things to consider. Anis mentioned that, from his experience exhibiting work, some people were reluctant to put on VR headsets that other visitors had already used. I also started thinking about what people expect when they see a VR headset. Most people probably assume they’re about to play a game or interact with something.I still wanted to make a film. I wanted the technology to contribute to the experience, not become the experience itself.
Unfortunately, I eventually had to scale back a lot of the interactive ideas. There was just so much to do with the animation, environments and everything else that I couldn’t realistically give the interactive systems the time they needed. I was disappointed that I couldn’t explore them properly, because they were a big part of what initially excited me about the project. But at some point, I had to be realistic about what I could actually finish.
Keeping The Original Idea Alive
Even though I moved away from VR and eventually dropped most of the interactive elements, I still wanted to hold on to some of what made the original idea interesting to me. One of the biggest things was the aspect ratio. The curved widescreen suggestion was what pushed me towards using a much wider format, and I eventually settled on 2560 × 1080. I really liked how much of the environment I could fit into the frame. It gave me more room to show the characters in relation to each other, rather than constantly cutting between close-ups.
I also started thinking quite carefully about how I positioned the parents. I wanted the composition to almost feel like two films happening at the same time. The mother would occupy one side of the screen and the father the other, but I didn’t want it to look like I had artificially placed them apart just for the sake of the composition. I was thinking about couples who live in the same house but almost live separate lives. They share the same physical space, but emotionally, it’s as though they’re in completely different places.
I wanted to bring that feeling into the frame. Even when both parents were in the same room, I wanted them to feel like they were occupying their own little worlds. Using wider focal lengths and showing more of the rooms also helped with this. I didn’t want the film to rely entirely on close-ups of the characters. I wanted the audience to see the space around them and feel like they were actually sitting somewhere inside the house.
Looking back, the final project ended up being quite different from the experience I originally imagined. I didn’t get to make the 360-degree interactive film I had initially been excited about, and I didn’t get to experiment with eye tracking in the way I wanted. But I don’t think the original idea disappeared completely. A lot of it ended up influencing how I approached the camera, the aspect ratio and the way I staged the characters. Even without the interactive elements, I was still trying to find ways to make the audience feel like they were inside this household, watching something that they couldn’t quite do anything about.